[plt-scheme] critique of some code

From: Matthias Felleisen (matthias at ccs.neu.edu)
Date: Sun Dec 6 23:14:38 EST 2009

uh, oh, I hate and/or nests? Does this make me a non-Schemer? 

On Dec 6, 2009, at 11:05 PM, Shriram Krishnamurthi wrote:

> Here's my version.
> 
> Zero, I assume you want the naive version, not something like the KMP
> or BM algorithms.
> 
> First, I changed your contract to return false instead of -1, because
> that's what a Schemer would have done.
> 
> Second, I converted to lists, because that's also what a Schemer would
> do (unless you were concerned about long strings, in which case anyway
> you'd use KMP/BM above some threshold).
> 
> Third, here's both the and/or version and the cond version.
> 
> Fourth, it's in TS.
> 
> S.
> 
> ----------------------------------------------------------------------
> #lang typed-scheme
> 
> (require scheme/list)
> (require scheme/bool)
> 
> (: string-index-of (String String -> (U Number Boolean)))
> 
> (define (string-index-of in for)
>  (sio/list (string->list in) (string->list for) 0))
> 
> (define: (sio/list [check-in : (Listof Char)]
>                   [check-for : (Listof Char)]
>                   [index : Number]) : (U Number Boolean)
>  (and (not (empty? check-in))
>       (or (and (prefix-of? check-for check-in) index)
>           (sio/list (rest check-in) check-for (add1 index)))))
> #|
>  (cond
>    [(empty? check-in) false]
>    [else (if (prefix-of? check-for check-in)
>              index
>              (sio/list (rest check-in) check-for (add1 index)))]))
> |#
> 
> (define: (prefix-of? [pre : (Listof Char)]
>                     [big : (Listof Char)]) : Boolean
>  (or (empty? pre)
>      (and (not (empty? big))
>           (char=? (first pre) (first big))
>           (prefix-of? (rest pre) (rest big)))))
> #|
>  (cond
>    [(empty? pre) true]
>    [(empty? big) false]
>    [else (and (char=? (first pre) (first big))
>               (prefix-of? (rest pre) (rest big)))]))
> |#
> 
> (define check-expect equal?)
> (check-expect (string-index-of "abcd" "a") 0)
> (check-expect (string-index-of "abc" "bc") 1)
> (check-expect (string-index-of "abcd" "d") 3)
> (check-expect (string-index-of "abcd" "de") false)
> (check-expect (string-index-of "abcd" "abcde") false)
> ----------------------------------------------------------------------
> _________________________________________________
>  For list-related administrative tasks:
>  http://list.cs.brown.edu/mailman/listinfo/plt-scheme



Posted on the users mailing list.